In a very fertile soil with plenty of organic matter, excellent drainage and perfect structure, additions of fertilizer would not be necessary. Unfortunately this perfect balance of soil fertility and plant food soil is seldom found, and even if found, will not remain perfect because of the loss of fertility through leaching, vaporization and use by plants.
Soil Fertility and Plant Food: Major Nutrients
So we need to amend our soils with ingredients that supply specific nutrients which can become available to plants. Plant nutrients in fertilizers are classified as major nutrients and micronutrients. The most important major nutrients are nitrogen (N), phosphorus (P) and potassium (K). Plants require these nutrients in relatively large amounts, and these are the nutrients most likely to be deficient for plant growth.
Soil Fertility and Plant Food: Secondary Nutrients
Other major nutrients, called secondary nutrients, are calcium (Ca), magnesium (Mg) and sulfur (S). They are also required in relatively large amounts but are less likely to be deficient. Micronutrients are essential for plant growth, but plants require relatively small amounts of them. They include boron (B), copper (Cu), iron (Fe), manganese (Mn), molybdenum (Mo) and zinc (Zn). These elements may also be referred to as minor or trace elements.
Soil Fertility and Plant Food: Synthetic Vs Natural
The debate continues to rage over which form of fertilizer is better, synthetic or natural. Proponents of synthetic fertilizers claim that all the essential elements can be supplied in greater quantity and at less cost than their natural counterparts.
Proponents of the natural, or organic fertilizers counter that indeed the synthetic fertilizers supply the chemical forms of the essential nutrients, but these materials, actually derived from crude oil, lack the necessary beneficial soil microorganisms that help to break down the nutrients into plant available forms.
It’s also been pointed out that the common overuse of chemical fertilizers has resulted in the buildup of harmful salts in the soil, excessive tissue growth resulting in weak plants susceptible to disease and insects, reduced drought tolerance and increased dependence on foreign oil.
Natural fertilizers like compost, manure, blood and bone meal, kelp, etc. all contribute to the quantity and health of beneficial bacteria, fungi and algae, which in turn benefit plant growth. An old adage among organic gardeners is “feed the soil, not the plants”.
In recent years a number of companies have developed granular, easily applied natural fertilizers consisting of mixtures of the traditional organic fertilizers listed above. These can be used in place of the “traditional” chemical or synthetic fertilizers.
Soil Fertility and Plant Food: Natural Products
I have used, and can recommend, natural fertilizer products from Ringer, Sustane, Gardens Alive and Whitney Farms. There are probably other natural fertilizer products from quality companies – let me know if you have a favorite.
Yes, natural fertilizers are more expensive because the raw ingredients are not as plentiful and preparation is more involved. An analogy is useful to explain the difference: you can get a burger and fries at the fast food place, or enjoy a well prepared meal of fresh ingredients at a quality restaurant. You’ll save a bit of money at the fast food place, but you may not be happy with the long term effects of regular meals there.
The prepared products mentioned above should not be used as a substitute for general soil improvement. Bulk compost and manures should be used as soil amendments when planting new landscapes and when mulching established plantings. In addition to supplying essential nutrients, these materials will add to the store of beneficial organisms, increase soil humus and improve the structure of both clay and sandy soils.
I’ve used natural fertilizers since the 1960’s and have found no reason to do otherwise. It’s good to know that I’m feeding my soil without any adverse effects to the environment.
See our complete list of garden how-to articles here.
Subscribe to our Sustainable Gardens Newsletter and Receive a
About Dan Eskelson
Dan has had his hands in the soil for most of his adult life as a gardener, landscaping contractor, golf course superintendent and landscape designer. When the ground freezes, he builds websites, produces video and plays the hammered dulcimer. Full bio here.